90 Day Fiancé: Who Is Mike Youngquist's New Girlfriend After Natalie & Marcia? (2025)

90 Day Fiancé star Mike Youngquist has a new girlfriend after his failed relationships with Natalie Mordovtseva and Marcia Brazil. Mike, a 39-year-old man from Sequim, starred in 90DF season 7 with Natalie when he went to Ukraine to meet her ahead of her K-1 visa approval. Mike and Natalie had met via mutual friends and were complete opposites. He believed in aliens and ate meat, while Natalie was religious and a vegetarian. They clashed over the idea of having babies. Natalie even broke up with Mike while he was leaving Kyiv but decided to give their relationship a second chance when her visa was approved.

Sadly, Mike and Natalie should have paid attention to the red flags as their marriage lasted for less than a year, and she soon left him. Mike had yet to divorce Natalie when she began dating a man called Josh Weinstein in Florida. Meanwhile, Mike shocked reality TV viewers when he was seen on Rock of Love with Bret Michaels star Marcia’s IG feed. The pair had dated on and off since August 2022 but in April 2023, Marcia confirmed she and Mike were no longer together because they lived too far away from each other to do anything serious and were unable to continue a long-distance relationship.

Mike Did A 'Soft Launch' Of His New Girlfriend In June

Mike first teased his Instagram followers with a girlfriend reveal in June 2023. He shared a selfie of him and his lady love sitting side by side but hid her face with a black blob to conceal her identity. Mike looked happy in the picture with his hand around the woman, but she sported a serious expression and the photo was also rotated sideways before he posted it. 90 Day Fiancé fans didn’t quite appreciate Mike’s post for his new girlfriend. Someone commented, “What’s the point of even posting this?” while a different fan wrote, “Don’t post photos of someone your 'dating' if you have to block her face out.”

Mike Was Accused Of Pranking Fans With Fake Girlfriend

A month later, Mike decided it was time for him to “hard launch” his girlfriend. However, his post misfired miserably. Mike captioned his selfie, “Blessed by the god of the universe for this one of a kind person means the world to me.” The sideways picture showed Mike and his girlfriend posing in a car with her leaning over his lap and placing one hand on the side of her head. This post further disappointed Mike’s followers and even confused some who commented things like, “Odd photo.... The woman looks photoshopped into the picture” and “She is photoshopped into this pic. Its so obvious. Smh.”

Mike’s followers observed that he had used a filter that made his skin blemish-free and gave him a slimmer appearance. However, some naysayers were certain that the woman was not real, and possibly “AI generated” and photoshopped into the photo by Mike, who got “40 pounds thinner and 15 years younger in a few weeks.”

Mike Is Dating A Woman Named Sara Rose

Interestingly, Mike finally decided to prove his critics wrong by sharing a video with his new girlfriend in December 2023. “Missing my sugar so much I love you baby always,” Mike wrote in his caption for the video from his date with his girlfriend in Las Vegas in September 2023. Mike did not tag his girlfriend this time either, but she revealed her identity in the comments section. A user named @src0791 posted a comment saying, “I love you so much my watermelon sugar king forever my love.” The private account belongs to a woman named Sara Rose as per the Snapchat ID mentioned in her bio.

Moreover, Mike’s girlfriend even replied to a fan in the comments. The fan wrote, “Met you both at a roulette table during Luke Bryan concert time. I’m a big fan of yours. Your sugar is beautiful, humble and family focused. Great seeing you happy man!” Sara told them, “I remember you,” thus confirming her identity. Mike and his girlfriend make a great pair and fans think they make for a “beautiful couple.” It remains to be seen if Mike will introduce her to 90 Day Fiancé viewers soon or will choose to keep his relationship away from reality TV.

Source: Mike Youngquist/Instagram, Mike Youngquist/Instagram, Mike Youngquist/Instagram, Sara Rose/Instagram